FRI 29 - 3 - 2024
 
Date: Feb 5, 2011
 
Barack Obama sees Egypt, but remembers Indonesia

By David Ignatius
Saturday, February 05, 2011


As President Barack Obama watched events unfold this past week in Egypt and the surrounding Arab world, he is said to have reflected on his own boyhood experiences in Indonesia – when the country was ruled by a corrupt, authoritarian leader who was later toppled by a reform movement.


Obama looks at the Egyptian drama through an unusual lens. He has experienced dictatorship first-hand, a world where “the strong man takes the weak man’s land,” as he quoted his Indonesian stepfather in his autobiography. The president came of age reading Frantz Fanon and other theorists of radical change. He is sometimes described as a “post-racial” figure, but it’s also helpful to think of him as a “post-colonial” man.


Obama’s policy decisions over the past several weeks have been guided by a sense that the fissures in Egyptian and Arab society have been building for a long time, and that, as one person familiar with his thinking says, “this is not something that can be put back in a box.”


While Obama thinks it’s important to protect American interests amid the turbulence, he believes that as a democracy, the United States can’t respond in the narrow way that, say, China would. He is said to have ended several meetings in the Situation Room over the past week with an admonition to think broadly about the process of change that’s under way now, and align U.S. policy with these larger themes.


The formative experiences of Obama’s life tell him that change in developing countries is inexorable, and that reform can often succeed. Not every popular movement turns out as disastrously as the Iranian revolution of 1979, Obama believes. There are positive models, including the “people power” movement that replaced Ferdinand Marcos in the Philippines in 1986, the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 and the overthrow in 1998 of the dictatorial President Suhartro in Indonesia, whom Obama remembers from his boyhood.


What shapes Obama’s thinking isn’t ideological so much as personal: When he talks to human-rights activists from overseas, he often recalls what it was like to live in an authoritarian country – where even in seemingly calm times, there was an omnipresent fear and tension. His Indonesian stepfather, Lolo, once admitted that he had seen a man killed “because he was weak.”


The lesson that Obama takes from Indonesia’s democratic revolt is that when the grip of authoritarian government has been loosened, it can’t easily be restored: A catharsis takes place that, over time, can lead to better governance and economic growth.

 

If Obama hasn’t publicly articulated these broad themes lately, that’s partly due to the rush of events – and also because of his reticent manner. He is not a man who likes to govern by anecdote. Critics have argued that Obama has been too slow to embrace the Egyptian protest movement. But he seems genuinely to believe that change is a matter for Egyptians, not Americans, and that too heavy an American hand would be counterproductive.


For a statement of the strategic ideas that guide Obama now, it’s useful to re-read his Cairo speech of June 4, 2009. The premise of that celebrated address was that America’s relationship with the Islamic world was broken.

“I’ve come here to Cairo to seek a new beginning between the United States and Muslims around the world, one based on mutual interest and mutual respect,” Obama said. That’s still the baseline, but it’s fair to say that the Cairo speech raised expectations in the Arab world without delivering on them. Indeed, this may be one modest factor in the “revolution of rising expectations” we are seeing on the streets in Tunis, Cairo, Sanaa and Amman.


Obama’s personal history gives him a unique opportunity to connect with the young generation that is making this volatile revolution. But it also makes Obama uniquely vulnerable to the charge that he is putting American security second to his hopes for an ephemeral process of change that could prove disastrous for American interests. The scenes this week of young protesters manning the barricades in Tahrir Square evoked “Les Miserables” or “Dr. Zhivago.” But we know those stories turned out badly for the good guys.


Obama’s challenge is to use his life experience – and his unusual ability as a communicator – to brace this process of change. He can identify with the idealistic young rebels in the street, but he also needs to reassure the world that American power is a steadying force at a time of upheaval.

 

Syndicated columnist David Ignatius is published twice weekly by THE DAILY STAR.


The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the Arab Network for the Study of Democracy
 
Readers Comments (0)
Add your comment

Enter the security code below*

 Can't read this? Try Another.
 
Inside:
Why Algeria will not go Egypt's way
When revolutionary euphoria subsides: Lessons from Ukraine
A letter from the Cedar Revolution to the Nile Revolution
Can Lebanon kill its own tribunal?
Egypt’s Youth are Responsible for Defending their Revolution from Those who Would Climb upon It
Just changing generals is not freedom
Mubarak, save Egypt and leave
Egypt's future in Egyptian hands
Social media are connecting Arab youths and politicians
The Mediterranean between sunny skies and clouds of pessimism
For the West, act of contrition time
Lost generations haunt Arab rulers
Can Egypt's military become platform for political change?
The Tunisian experience is likely to mean evolution in Morocco
Why Arabs have airbrushed Lebanon out
The Middle East's freedom train has just left the station
For better or worse, Arab history is on the move
Democracy: not just for Americans
Tunisia may be a democratic beacon, but Islamists will profit
Is this a Gdansk moment for the Arabs?
Ben Ali's ouster was the start, and Mubarak will follow
Mubarak's only option is to go
Egypt's battle requires focus
The Arabs' future is young and restless
Arab rulers' only option is reform
Exhilarating Arab revolts, but what comes afterward?
Hezbollah enters uncharted territory
Resisting change fans the flames
To participate or not to participate?
choice decisive for Lebanon
Lebanon typifies Arab political poverty
Between Tunisia’s Uprising and Lebanon’s Tribunal
Lebanon, Between Partnership and Unilateralism
What might Hezbollah face once the trial begins?
In Lebanon, echoes of the Iraq crisis
Is Hezbollah's eye mainly on Syria?
Egypt's Copt crisis is one of democracy
The thrill and consequences of Tunisia for the Arab region
Three Arab models are worth watching
Tunisia riots offer warning to Arab governments
Tunisia has a lesson to teach
Amid stalemate, let negotiations begin!
Time for Lebanese to re-think stances
North Africa at a tipping point
The Options Available When Faced with the Failure of Arab Governments
Latifa and Others
The past Lebanese decade
Troubling trends in this Arab new year
An independent Egyptian Web site gives women a voice
Yet another Arab president for life
Beyond the STL
Fight the roots of extremism
Fractures prevail as Arabs cap 2010
Truth about injustice will help reduce Muslim radicalization
Christian flight would spell the end for the Arab world
Defining success in the Lebanon tribunal
60% of the Lebanese and 40% of Shiites Support the Choice of Justice
Without remedy, Lebanon faces abyss
The Saudi succession will affect a broad circle of countries
The Arab world faces a silent feminist revolution
The canard of regime change in Syria
Egypt faces a legitimacy crisis following flawed elections
Lebanon: Reform starts with politicians
Human Rights: Three priorities for Lebanon
What's changed?
Monitoring in the dark
Myths about America
Lessons from the fringes
On campus, not all get to vote
'Your credit is due to expire'!
Blood for democracy
Lebanon can solve its own problems
The Janus-like nature of Arab elections
Social Structural Limitations for Democratization in the Arab World
Jordan’s Public Forums Initiative
Islamic Historic Roots of the Term
Copyright 2024 . All rights reserved