THU 28 - 3 - 2024
 
Date: Jan 19, 2011
 
The thrill and consequences of Tunisia for the Arab region

By Rami G. Khouri

Wednesday, January 19, 2011


Two great questions loom after the overthrow of the regime of former Tunisian President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali: How smoothly and how quickly will the Tunisian people transition to a more democratic form of government that can address their grievances and improve their life prospects? How much, and what kind of, impact will the Tunisian popular revolution have on other Arab countries? Both of these questions will require some time before we have clear answers, but several important dimensions already seem clear.


The two most important are that popular grievances and the political governance system in Tunisia broadly mirror the same realities throughout most Arab states. Widespread popular economic distress and political indignity, alongside security-based autocratic rule and top-level corruption and profligacy, make the entire region potentially vulnerable to political turbulence. Tunisia exposed exactly how thin was the police-based rule of the Ben Ali regime, which crumbled rapidly when it met sustained domestic resistance. Some other Arab leaders, whether monarchs or lifelong presidents or something in between, would have not fled the country so quickly; they would have put up a fight to stay in power, partly because they have stronger organic links to major constituencies in society.


The third point is that the 22 Arab countries are not a monolithic entity. Each country has distinct local conditions, socioeconomic development level, patriarchal governance, and political culture (in other words secular, Islamist, tribal, nationalist, pan-Arab, and so on). Moreover, we are really speaking about two distinct Arab worlds – the wealthy oil producers governed by paternalistic welfare states that take care of citizens’ material needs, and the rest of the Arabs who are defined by low-income conditions, widespread un- and under-employment, and political autocracy.


Polling data by Gallup from the entire Arab world, recently published by the Silatech group in Doha, highlights the very strong divergence in worldviews among youth in the rich and the poor Arab countries. It shows, for example, that 15-29-year-old young Arab men and women have a strong desire to migrate permanently in quest of a job and a better life, but this desire is very uneven: It reaches 40-45 percent in some countries like Yemen, Morocco and Tunisia, but only 5-6 percent of youth in the Gulf states. Confidence in their government and judicial system is relatively low among Arab youth – around 50 percent on average, going down to 34 percent in poorer Arab societies – while in the oil-producing states it is 90 percent. A few desperate young men have turned themselves into human torches in Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt and Mauritania, but we are unlikely to see any such thing in Kuwait, Qatar or the United Arab Emirates.

 

The fourth point most immediately relevant is that we have virtually no experience in the two exciting and historic phenomena now taking place in Tunisia: Arab popular self-determination and transition from autocracy to democracy. The Arab countries have provided a novel form of modern nationhood in which they enjoyed independence without real self-determination (because their citizens mostly never really had an opportunity to define governance systems and state ideologies); and most experience statehood without full sovereignty (because they depend on external powers to keep them in place and solvent).


We are fortunate that Tunisia is the first example of self-determination in Arab populist governance, because Tunisian society is relatively secular with a range of ideological views – from the Marxist and labor left to the Islamist and tribal right – that neatly captures the pluralistic character of the Arab world.


Observers who wonder how Tunisia mirrors the rest of the region would do well to note the core grievances that Tunisians articulated during this transition. These grievances are widely shared with the nearly 90 percent of all Arabs who are poor – and thus they point the way to needed reforms across the region. They are about corruption, lack of political and fiscal accountability, non-credible electoral and political systems, the absence of democratic principles, abuse of power, and excessive reliance on unchecked police power.


Consequently, heading off similar revolts in other Arab countries would seem to require that long-serving rulers make real changes in four principal areas: freedom of media and expression; more honest political representation of citizens in Parliament; greater accountability in government budgets (including ruling and royal family spending); and civilian oversight over the security and intelligence services. These changes will not come easily or quickly.


Tunisia’s ongoing transition will have continuing impact around the Arab world, especially with the massive television coverage from Al-Jazeera-led satellite services. What a thrill – what an absolute, exhilarating thrill – it is after half a century of mass Arab degradation and dehumanization to watch an Arab society begin to make a transition toward something more noble, or simply more normal.

 

Rami G. Khouri is published twice weekly by THE DAILY STAR.


The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the Arab Network for the Study of Democracy
 
Readers Comments (0)
Add your comment

Enter the security code below*

 Can't read this? Try Another.
 
Inside:
Why Algeria will not go Egypt's way
When revolutionary euphoria subsides: Lessons from Ukraine
A letter from the Cedar Revolution to the Nile Revolution
Mubarak, save Egypt and leave
Barack Obama sees Egypt, but remembers Indonesia
Just changing generals is not freedom
Egypt’s Youth are Responsible for Defending their Revolution from Those who Would Climb upon It
Can Lebanon kill its own tribunal?
Egypt's future in Egyptian hands
Social media are connecting Arab youths and politicians
The Mediterranean between sunny skies and clouds of pessimism
For the West, act of contrition time
Why Arabs have airbrushed Lebanon out
The Tunisian experience is likely to mean evolution in Morocco
Can Egypt's military become platform for political change?
Lost generations haunt Arab rulers
Democracy: not just for Americans
For better or worse, Arab history is on the move
The Middle East's freedom train has just left the station
Mubarak's only option is to go
Ben Ali's ouster was the start, and Mubarak will follow
Is this a Gdansk moment for the Arabs?
Tunisia may be a democratic beacon, but Islamists will profit
Egypt's battle requires focus
The Arabs' future is young and restless
Hezbollah enters uncharted territory
Exhilarating Arab revolts, but what comes afterward?
Arab rulers' only option is reform
Resisting change fans the flames
To participate or not to participate?
choice decisive for Lebanon
Lebanon typifies Arab political poverty
Between Tunisia’s Uprising and Lebanon’s Tribunal
Lebanon, Between Partnership and Unilateralism
What might Hezbollah face once the trial begins?
In Lebanon, echoes of the Iraq crisis
Is Hezbollah's eye mainly on Syria?
Egypt's Copt crisis is one of democracy
Three Arab models are worth watching
Tunisia riots offer warning to Arab governments
Tunisia has a lesson to teach
Amid stalemate, let negotiations begin!
Time for Lebanese to re-think stances
North Africa at a tipping point
The Options Available When Faced with the Failure of Arab Governments
Latifa and Others
The past Lebanese decade
Troubling trends in this Arab new year
An independent Egyptian Web site gives women a voice
Yet another Arab president for life
Beyond the STL
Fight the roots of extremism
Fractures prevail as Arabs cap 2010
Truth about injustice will help reduce Muslim radicalization
Christian flight would spell the end for the Arab world
Defining success in the Lebanon tribunal
60% of the Lebanese and 40% of Shiites Support the Choice of Justice
Without remedy, Lebanon faces abyss
The Saudi succession will affect a broad circle of countries
The Arab world faces a silent feminist revolution
The canard of regime change in Syria
Egypt faces a legitimacy crisis following flawed elections
Lebanon: Reform starts with politicians
Human Rights: Three priorities for Lebanon
What's changed?
Monitoring in the dark
Myths about America
Lessons from the fringes
On campus, not all get to vote
'Your credit is due to expire'!
Blood for democracy
Lebanon can solve its own problems
The Janus-like nature of Arab elections
Social Structural Limitations for Democratization in the Arab World
Jordan’s Public Forums Initiative
Islamic Historic Roots of the Term
Copyright 2024 . All rights reserved